I don't think I've said hi to you before, so let me just start with a quick hello.
Hi!
Hehe... Okay, now onto the real critique.
Overall, I was not extremely impressed (originality-wise). I understand using the film's setup as a springboard for the fanfic, but I didn't understand why you essentially took the movie's dialogue and just added in some description. Isn't half the fun of fanfiction making it your own? Give Peter, Susan, Edmund, and Lucy the personality nuances YOU want them to have, otherwise, what's the point of the fanfiction?
You do, however, get points for this being well-written. I think fanfiction has become infamous for the amount of badly written travesties out there. You steered clear of that. And you do get credit for adding in an original character. I always think that the untold story of Narnia is in those characters that like movie extras. And you used one! Yay!
A couple of nitpicks:
Double space! Please! It makes reading things on-screen so much easier, especially since tab doesn't work out too well here either.
Peter and Susan then landed on their behinds. Much surprising since they were inside a wardrobe and not in some park. And much more surprising was the fact that what they had landed on, whatever it was, was wet.
I think you should eliminate the "then" in the first sentence and rephrase the second sentence since, as it stands, it is a fragment. Plus I just don't like the word behind as a synonym for butt. I have no idea why.
i.e. (this is just a suggestion; I am not saying this the best way to write it!)
Peter and Susan landed on their backsides - surprising, considering that they were in a wardrobe and not in some park. But much more surprising..." etc.
“Impossible!” Susan exclaimed, gazing at her snow-covered surroundings in wonder. Peter couldn’t help but gape openly. The land, whatever it was called, was magical. The beauty of the place awed him. Where are we?
You should make this one paragraph into two, since it concerns two different characters' actions. Also, why does he care what it's called right away? Wouldn't most people be more concerned about where the heck they were?
i.e. [i]Impossible!" Susan exclaimed, gazing at her snow-covered surroundings in wonder.
Peter couldn't help but gaze openly. The land, wherever it existed, was magical. The beauty of the place awed him. Where were they?[/i]
They didn’t believe her. They made her out to be some delusional little girl. And it turned out she was telling the gospel truth. “I suppose saying sorry won’t quite cover it.”
I think combining the sentences would make this flow better.
i.e. They hadn't believed her. They had made her out to be some delusional little, and it turned out that she was telling the gospel truth.
OR
They hadn't believed her - they had even made her out to be deluded - and then it turned out that she was telling the gospel truth.
The figure looked at the four children, appraising them all, memorizing them.
I like that line.
The older boy, and presumably the oldest of the children, looked to be about fifteen or sixteen narnian summers. He was tall and handsome and had sandy hair. It was too far to make out the color of his eyes, but if the figure saw him again, he would be recognized. Especially in those funny-looking clothes he wore… that all the children wore.
Should "Narnian" be capitalized?
Also, you might consider replacing the ellipses with a simpler, cleaner dash. ("...clothes he wore - that all the children wore.")
“Alright!” The younger boy almost threw his hands up in frustration. “I’m sorry!”
“It’s alright,” the younger girl – Lucy – said smugly. “I guess small children just don’t know when to stop pretending.”
"All right" should be two words.
It was simply dragging to have to follow the children and try to keep away from the White Witch’s spies.
"Simply dragging"... What does that mean? You might try a different phrase here to fully convey the "this bites!" feel that you're trying to get across.
The figure wasn’t sure if the beaver was a Beaver.
Who exactly is "the figure"? The one watching the Pevensies? But I do like this line just the same...
One child held back, though… The younger boy. He looked at the two hills in the distance, where the White Witch, tyrannical despot of Narnia and Queen of Evil, lived.
Again, consider eliminating the ellipses. They're...distracting.
I haven't seen a lot of Narnia fanfiction out there, so I'm looking forward to seeing what you do with this.
Hope some of my comments helped, and thanks for the read!
Points: 17580
Reviews: 798
Donate